A quality of earnings (QoE) report is an independent review of a company's profits before someone buys it. It tests whether the earnings a seller reports are real and will repeat. Buyers use it to confirm they are buying what they were told they are buying.
A forensic accountant lifts the hood and checks the engine. You are the one paying for it, so you want to know it is the engine the seller described.
Who needs a quality of earnings report?
Anyone buying a business. Some buyers have done one deal and some have done a hundred, and they all check the numbers. That includes searchers and other buyers in entrepreneurship through acquisition (ETA), independent sponsors and private equity groups.
It matters most if you are signing a personal guarantee. If you are guaranteeing millions of dollars of debt, you need to know the earnings are real before you close. Do not buy a business and guarantee the debt without a QoE.
Why have QoE reports become so common?
Baby boomers are retiring and many of their kids do not want the business, so a lot of companies are coming to market. People call it the silver tsunami. At the same time, more buyers would rather own a steady, cash-flowing business than chase a venture-backed startup. Some buy one company and then buy more in the same market, the way private equity rolls up businesses, so the group shares overhead.
More deals means more borrowed money, and lenders now want proof. For many larger SBA acquisition loans, a QoE is required.
What does a quality of earnings report look at?
Proof of cash
This ties the general ledger to the bank statements. The cash the books say came in has to match the cash the bank says came in.
Profit analysis
The report looks at trends and seasonality and separates recurring earnings from one-time items. Say the business landed a big government contract that will not come again, or a large project in a development that is now built. That revenue was real, but it will not repeat. The report adjusts earnings so you value only what will continue.
Management review
The reviewer goes through the org chart and interviews the team. Who wears several hats? Sometimes the owner's spouse does the books and is not paid. When the owner sells, the spouse leaves too, and you have to hire someone. That can take about $60,000 off earnings to backfill the role.
We also see handshake deals. A friend lets the business use a parking lot, an office or a warehouse and charges no rent. That arrangement often ends when ownership changes.
Liabilities and cash flow
The review also covers off-balance-sheet liabilities, tax liabilities and cash flow.
Working capital
Deals often die here at the negotiating table. Working capital is the cash a business needs to pay its people and vendors while it brings in revenue. The working capital peg sets how much stays in the business at closing. The seller wants it close to empty and the buyer wants it close to full.
It is like buying a nice car with no gas in it. You cannot drive it home.
What are the different types of QoE reports?
There are three common levels. A sniff test is a quick check that the numbers smell right before you spend more. A QoE light is narrower and often covers one year of financials. A full QoE goes deeper and often covers three years.
Sophisticated buyers, private equity especially, often work in phases. They start with the sniff test and go deeper as the deal gets more serious. The scope can also be tailored, since some parts of the report matter more in certain industries.
In our experience, most buyers who are about to sign a personal guarantee order the full report.
Is a quality of earnings report the same as an audit?
No. An audit checks whether financial statements follow accounting rules. A QoE asks whether the earnings will carry on once you own the company. Audited statements do not replace one.
What happens if you skip it?
You find the problems after you own the business. If you personally guaranteed the loan, you still owe the debt even when the earnings turn out to be wrong. It does not matter whose fault it was.
Most of what we find is not fraud. Most owners are not trying to deceive anyone, and many have already spent the proceeds and moved on. You have to ask the question or you miss it. A QoE asks it for you.
Frequently asked questions
Who needs a quality of earnings report?
Anyone buying a business. It matters most for buyers who are personally guaranteeing debt.
What is the difference between a QoE light and a full QoE?
A light report is usually narrower and often covers one year. A full report goes deeper and often covers three.
Is a quality of earnings report an audit?
No. An audit checks accounting compliance. A QoE tests whether earnings are real and will repeat.
Do I need a QoE for an SBA loan?
For many larger SBA 7(a) acquisition loans, yes. Since October 1, 2026, acquisitions priced at $3 million or more require one.
Who does the work at Frak Finance
Our reports are prepared by CPAs from Big Four transaction advisory and audit practices. They have done hundreds of these for private equity firms.
Buying a business? Book an intro call with Tom (opens in a new tab) to talk through the right level of QoE for your deal.